Comparison

CircleUp Planner vs. Homeschool Manager

Homeschool Manager and CircleUp Planner cost about the same and both keep grades, attendance and a transcript. They differ in how the plan gets made. Homeschool Manager gives you a week to fill and rearrange. The Planner starts from your curriculum's real lesson counts and lays out the whole year.

Here is the side-by-side, including when Homeschool Manager is the better fit.

The short answer

Pick Homeschool Manager if…

  • You would rather plan a week at a time than see the whole year laid out.
  • You track volunteer or service hours for a transcript.
  • You write your own lessons, or your curriculum has no fixed lesson count.

Pick CircleUp Planner if…

  • Your curriculum is in our catalog and you do not want to type its lessons in.
  • You want to know in August whether each book will finish by June.
  • Your co-op runs on CircleUp, so its days and breaks plan around themselves.
  • 20% less a year at list price, 41% less at the founding price.

What each costs

Homeschool Manager, yearly
$49/yr
CircleUp Planner, yearly
$39/yr
CircleUp Planner, founding price (yearly, by March 31, 2027)
$29/yr
Monthly: Homeschool Manager vs. CircleUp Planner
$5.99 vs. $4.99

At list price that is 20% less a year and 17% less a month. Homeschool Manager's pricing page lists one set of features on every plan, so there is no upgrade to plan for on either side. Their pricing page does not say how many students a plan covers; the Planner covers every child in the family.

Homeschool Manager figures are from homeschoolmanager.com, checked November 2026. Check their site before you decide.

Side by side

Where their site does not describe something, we say so rather than assume it is missing.

CircleUp PlannerHomeschool Manager
Yearly$39 ($29 founding price)$49
Monthly$4.99$5.99
Free trial30 days, no card30 days
Every child on one planNot stated on their pricing page
Curriculum lesson counts built inOver 200 curricula and levelsYou enter lessons in a lesson plan
Lays out the whole year from your school daysPlans a week at a time, by design
When a day goes wrongThe rest of the year re-flows; you see the new finish dateDrag the task to another day
Grades and transcriptsYes, with GPA and a college-readiness checkYes, with year and cumulative GPA
Attendance records
Reading or book listsReading list in the portfolio
Volunteer hours
Children check off their own dayOwn login per childOn a printed list or their phone
State record checklists21 statesNot described on their site
Your co-op's classes and breaks in your planWhen the co-op uses CircleUpNot described on their site

A week to fill, or a year laid out

Homeschool Manager is built around the week. You hold the year's work in lesson plans, pull this week's onto the schedule, and drag a task to Thursday when Tuesday falls apart. Its own site says it plans a week at a time on purpose, rather than locking in a calendar in August. If you like deciding each Sunday what the week holds, that is a good way to work.

CircleUp Planner works the other way round. Tell it your school days, your breaks and each child's curriculum, and it places every lesson for the year: Teaching Textbooks Math 4 is 119 lessons and 17 quizzes, 136 school days; a level of All About Reading is planned as 20 minutes a day. When a day goes wrong, everything after it moves and you see the new finish date, so you find out in October, not May, that a book will not finish.

See it for Saxon Math, Math-U-See, The Good and the Beautiful Language Arts, Teaching Textbooks and All About Reading, or read how it compares with Homeschool Planet.

Questions families ask

Is CircleUp Planner cheaper than Homeschool Manager?

A little. Homeschool Manager is $49 a year or $5.99 a month. CircleUp Planner is $39 a year (20% less) or $4.99 a month, and families who subscribe yearly by March 31, 2027 pay $29 a year for as long as they stay. Both start with a 30-day trial. The price gap is small enough that the way each one plans should decide it, not the price.

What is the real difference between them?

Where the lessons come from. In Homeschool Manager you put the year's lessons into a lesson plan yourself and pull work onto each week. In CircleUp Planner you pick the curriculum and level, and the Planner already knows how many lessons, tests and chapters it has, lays them across your school days and moves them when a day goes wrong. If your curriculum is not in our catalog, you add it by lessons or pages and it is laid out the same way.

Does CircleUp Planner track volunteer hours like Homeschool Manager?

No. Homeschool Manager tracks a student's volunteer hours; the Planner does not. If service hours are part of your high schooler's transcript, that is a fair reason to choose Homeschool Manager.

We are in a co-op. Does that change anything?

If your co-op runs on CircleUp, its classes, breaks and homework flow into your plan, and you get 20% off the Planner when the co-op is on a paid plan. Homeschool Manager lets you put co-op classes on a transcript next to your home courses; its site does not describe connecting to a co-op's own schedule.

Try it on this year's curriculum

Add what each child uses and see the year laid out. 30 days free, no card, and your records stay yours if you stop.